Wednesday, October 8, 2008

In Search of Perfection: Unfinished Literary Masterpieces



In Search of Perfection:


Unfinished Literary Masterpieces




How many great cathedrals remain unfinished!

—Marcel Proust, Time Regained



Whenever people tell me that they’ve never finished Franz Kafka’s novel The Trial, I always reply, “Well, neither did he.” In fact, Kafka never finished any of his three novels. He was a consummate perfectionist, but he had very little stamina as a writer, and he was never able to bring anything longer than “The Metamorphosis” to perfect consummation. The unfinished states of Amerika, The Trial, and The Castle have in fact given rise to comical critical conceits treating their fragmentary texts as somehow complete and forming an independent aesthetic of their own. In a completely different approach to a text’s lack of completeness, when discovering that Edmund Spenser’s The Faerie Queene was only half finished, many readers respond with a combination of exasperation and relief: “Good God! It could have actually been longer?”

Beauvais Cathedral
In his great study of the Middle Ages, Mont Saint Michel and Chartres, Henry Adams writes of the unfinished cathedral of Beauvais as perhaps the pinnacle of what Gothic architecture could have achieved. Although it’s hard to imagine anything more sublime than Chartres Cathedral, the full plan for Beauvais, which has resulted in an astonishing stone half-sketch, was grander and more unified than any of the completed marvels of the Île-de-France. Likewise, many of literature’s greatest and most ambitious works astound us even in their unfinished state and have stood as monuments to humanity’s dual nature as infinite imaginers who are also finite beings bounded by time and space.

Aside from Shakespeare’s cosmically dense condensations of universal reflection (being relatively short plays rather than towering epics), Dante’s Divine Comedy is often considered to be the single greatest example of a literary work to achieve total perfection within its intended bounds and aesthetic. Dante finished his lifework in 1320, just a year before he died, and even though Dante’s life was unenviable in many ways, his great poem stands as a masterpiece toward which so many subsequent artists aspire.

Dante’s main model (and guide within the geography of his poem’s first two books) was Vergil, whose magisterial Aeneid was considered by much of Late Antiquity and by all of the Middle Ages (when the Greek Homer was lost) to be the finest book of creative literature ever written, reigning supreme for the 1338 years between his death (19 BCE) and the completion of the Comedy. Vergil—whose name was conflated with the Latin word for “virtue” in the Middle Ages and was re-spelled Virgil—worked on his Roman national epic for the last eleven years of his life, blending together the story of Aeneas’ mythic founding of Rome with as many of city’s other founding myths as possible, taking up
A bust of Virgil in Naples
Homer’s depiction of the sack of Troy in the
Iliad and aiming its narrative toward the apotheosis of Vergil’s friend and patron Augustus Caesar. He was unable to complete the poem to his satisfaction, however, dying just as he was reportedly setting aside an additional three years to lick it into shape (his revision method was likened by his peers to the folk belief that bear cubs are born as formless masses and are then licked into the correct form by their mothers), and on his deathbed he asked his friends to burn his imperfect manuscript. Kafka made a similar request to his friend Max Brod, and thankfully for humanity, both of these (perhaps disingenuous) requests were ignored. What’s fascinating about the Aeneid is that, as a story, its narrative and vision and scope are almost entirely realized, and in translation it’s difficult for many readers to tell that it’s unfinished, but in the original there remain a handful of lines throughout the poem whose hexameters were either incomplete or contained clearly provisional/stopgap endings. Unlike in our own time of total poetic freedom, Classical poetry was simply considered “wrong” if a line didn’t conform to its meter, and beyond these prosodic concerns, there are in fact dozens of glaring problems with the Aeneid’s imperfectly revised state that make readers uncertain about many of the poem’s meanings and intentions and overall thrust.

The Death of Anchises. Engraving from a German
childrens’ picture-book version of the Aeneid,
by G. J. Lang and G. C. Eimmart, 1688
Vergil worked on the poem piecemeal, and some of its twelve books are more completely integrated with themselves and with the overall text than others, and book three—despite the dizzying multitudes that its lines contain, most memorably its vivid depiction of the horrifying cyclopes at its close—features a number of especially glaring lacunae that confuse attentive and inattentive readers alike. On a prosodic level, book three contains Vergil’s only hexameter whose meaning is incomplete (as opposed to the full poem’s other half-dozen incomplete lines, which make complete narrative sense and are only metrically incomplete), but beyond this missing step, book three’s other holes throw much of the surrounding books’ seeming seamlessness into serious imbalance. The most glaringly missing scene in the whole of the Aeneid is the death of Aeneas’ father, Anchises, which should have been narrated in book three when the Trojans arrive in Sicily. Vergil refers to this death scene throughout the poem, but this isn’t the modernist innovation of Ford Maddox Ford’s novel The Good Soldier, where the key scene is alluded to again and again and described in fragments throughout the book but not actually shown; it’s a real, detrimental hole in the text.

Map from an early copy of the Aeneid
When Aeneas and his crew later return to Sicily in book five after their time at Carthage in book four, the narrative describes their reunion with the Sicilian King Acestes as if he were an established ally that we recognize from the earlier book, but this is in fact the first time he’s appeared in the poem’s pages, and readers have to assume that he would have been described if Vergil had finished filling out book three, which is some fifty lines shorter than the Aeneid’s second shortest book. Book three also features confusing attempts on Aeneas’ part to build his people’s new city on three different sites, seeming to forget that the ghost of his dead wife Creusa specifically told him in book two during the burning of Troy that he would found a second Troy in Hesperia (aka Italy). At one point in book three, on the island of Delos, the priest-king Anius prophesies that the Trojans will return to their progenitor Dardanus’ homeland, which Anchises interprets as Crete, but then in Crete Aeneas dreams that his household gods tell him that he’s actually destined for Italy, which is revealed to be a dual homeland for Dardanus. Readers unfamiliar with the Aeneid’s textual problems are simply baffled about why Aeneas doesn’t remember his wife’s words from book two and continue single-mindedly on his way to Italy, likening the anxious hero’s confused stops and starts to Hamlet’s uncertainty about the truth of his mission and destiny when in fact playgoers already know that the ghost of his father isn’t just a hallucination but rather a real presence that’s corroborated by several other characters. Vergil would have presumably reconciled all of these problems during his three years of revisions, perhaps either making Creusa’s words in book two more ambiguous, or else eliminating Aeneas’ false starts in attempting to found a new city over and over again in book three before finally arriving in his destined Italy.

The Death of Palinarus. Unidentified.
While book three and its surrounding narrative threads contain the most jarring inconsistencies, several later books have interesting and often fascinating lapses too. In book five the helmsman Palinarus’ death at sea is described as being caused by the god of sleep dragging him down into the water during his watch, but when Aeneas meets Palinarus in the underworld in book six, the helmsman says that “no god drowned me in open waters” and describes how some force dragged him and the ship’s rudder over the water toward Italy, where he was killed by natives. Book seven has another lapse, where Vergil refers to Anchises as having made the prophecy that the Trojans would suffer so much hunger in Italy that they’d eat their platters, while it was actually Celaeno, the leader of the Harpies, who had earlier (again, in book three) spoken this dire prediction as a curse.

Agreement between Camilla and Turnus,
by Francesco de Mura, 1765
The Aeneid’s main inconsistencies in its second half—Vergil’s self-proclaimed “greater labor,” dealing with the subject of arms and modeled closely on Homer’s first book, the Iliad, while the first half of the Aeneid conversely deals with Aeneas the man and is loosely modeled on Homer’s sequel, the Odyssey—consist less of dramatic informational lapses than of questions of focus and stress and characterization. The second half of the Aeneid seems to be much more cleanly revised than the first, with thrillingly vivid battle scenes interspersed with deeply empathetic and integrated character and relationship studies that work together to heighten the reader’s edge-of-the-seat engagement with the poem’s rich tapestry of themes, but even in this tighter series of books there are odd imbalances that leave the reader wondering why some of the scenes don’t seem to be fully aware of the material in all of the others. While the Aeneid’s most empathetic and memorable book—book four—deals with Dido’s love for Aeneas and pain over losing him, with echoes from that episode washing over the entire structure of the poem and reverberating back like waves bouncing off of distant shores, it’s the remarkable personalities and presences of two of the second half’s female characters that strike the reader as largely missing from the rest of the narrative. Although the amazing Amazon-like warrior Camilla is briefly alluded to in books one and seven, her extraordinary battle sequences in book eleven seem a bit too isolated from the rest of the poem and feel like they could have been more substantially foreshadowed and integrated into Vergil’s characterizations of Aeneas’ Italian enemies. She just seems to show up and disappear so quickly, without anywhere near enough preparation. Even more dramatically abrupt, Turnus’ water-nymph sister Juturna flashes through the Aeneid’s final book, colluding with Juno to protect Turnus from Aeneas (Juturna’s name is a combination of Juno and Turnus), and her intense devotion to both her brother and Juno calls attention to her stark absence from the entire rest of the poem. If Turnus’ sister is a demi-god, why isn’t she more integrated into the text? Her scenes, like Camilla’s, are strikingly memorable and richly elaborated, with both women’s personalities and desires given full staging, and so considering Vergil’s gift for both empathy and subtlety, especially in portraying the female characters Creusa and Dido, it seems probable that he would have better woven the two woman warriors’ presences into the poem’s narrative thread had he been able to complete his final revisions.

Nisus and Euryalus,
by Jean-Baptiste Roman, 1827
Similarly, while many of the portraits of the male warriors in the poem’s second half sear themselves into the reader’s imagination before they get cut down in battle—especially the beloved friends Nisus and Euryalus, who open up the poem’s most philosophically compelling ideas just before going on the murderous rampage that ends their lives, contrasted later by a characterization almost as empathetic as Dido’s (and almost as challenging for a Roman audience): the Etruscan king Mezentius, whom the reader has long come to despise but then grows to feel deep compassion for in his last moments, having seen him suffer over his son’s death—too often the battle scenes instead tear through body after body without letting the reader grasp the dying characters’ full personalities or importance. On the one hand, perhaps Roman readers would have had a more rooted understanding of these dying characters than we do today, our inability to feel their importance merely stemming from our own distanced ignorance, but on the other hand perhaps these more slashingly rendered battle scenes are something of a critique of Homer’s constantly interrupting rehearsals of each dying warrior’s bloodline and history in the Iliad, with each death stopping the narrative flow to read a bit like the rules of a football game, where for every minute of play the action stops for several minutes of formulaic busywork. Vergil’s battle scenes are far more exciting and fluid than Homer’s, but in their brevity there’s a diminishment of the reader’s access to the emotional importance of each life and death, as well as to a larger grasp of the poem’s world, which in Homer is endlessly vast because of how well documented it all is on the page itself rather than being merely suggested or implied or assumed, and it’s impossible to say where Vergil would have shifted his poem’s balance between drama and totality had he survived to finalize his revisions. It’s also possible that his battle scenes were completed to his liking and are simply miscalculated in how well they make us feel their power.

These critiques of the Aeneid’s second half may seem like nitpicking compared to the poem’s other more obvious lacunae, but they strike the reader as being in marked contrast to the way Vergil seamlessly weaves his themes and narrative materials together into what now stands as one of the world’s most silken narrative tapestries. Rolling so many of Rome’s origin myths into one dazzlingly entertaining and integrated package, Vergil pulls off one of literature’s greatest balancing acts as he reconciles the needs of so many competing narrative and political pressures, reaching such a remarkable degree of poetic concord that his instances of imperfect harmony seem totally weird and glaring to us. Thankfully, his final work’s positive achievements weren’t discarded along with its flaws, leaving posterity with a lustrous, near-perfect work of art that adds an incalculable amount of richness to the way we envision and experience and explain ourselves as human beings.

An illumination from The Romance of the Rose
A fascinating and very different example of an unfinished masterpiece is the medieval epic The Romance of the Rose. The first 4,058 lines of this allegorical love poem were written by Guillaume de Lorris, who died in 1237. An anonymous writer added sixty-one lines to “complete” the poem, but then half a century later Jean de Meun added an astounding 17,622 lines to make the poem into a true romantic epic. This of course raises the question of whose poem this really is. Many prefer de Lorris’ more focused courtly approach, while many others prefer de Meun’s more expansive philosophical scope. Clearly de Meun makes the totality of the poem his own, but as we’re left with a very unusual and uniquely beautiful two-stage cathedral-poem built in widely different styles, perhaps we don’t really need to decide who it really “belongs to,” but rather to think of it as two interrelated testaments to the art of courtly and philosophical love. Similarly, Chartres Cathedral has a Romanesque foundation, and one of its two towers is considered to be the purest of all Romanesque structures, but a fire in 1194 inspired the master builders to revise and expand the cathedral’s plan in the new Gothic style, resulting in lines in the overall structure that don’t harmonize with each other, the unrevisability of the stone foundation keeping it forever out of sync with the rest of the design: a kind of stone harbinger of de Lorris/de Meun’s lopsided paper rose later in the century.

An illumination from The Canterbury Tales
Perhaps the most famously incomplete literary masterwork is Geoffrey Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales, whose various parts were composed off and on for more than a decade and left in almost complete disorder upon the poet’s death in 1400. The collection is meant to encompass tales told by somewhere between twenty-nine and thirty-one pilgrims on their way to and from St. Thomas à Becket’s shrine at Canterbury. Each pilgrim is supposed to tell one tale on the way to Canterbury and one on the way back, but only twenty-four tales were written, and they’re often in different forms—some are in prose, and many are in verses of different meter. The geography and order of the tales are often confused, and most of the actual tales themselves haven’t been reconciled at all with the plan in the poem’s General Prologue. The vivid writing and the deep penetration into human nature that the enormous incomplete mass contains have left an indelible imprint on the world’s collective literary mind, however. Having innovated character writing in a way that paved the way for Shakespeare’s infinitely shaded troupe, Chaucer has given us something far more valuable than mere perfection.

Like all English writers of the Renaissance, Edmund Spenser idolized Chaucer, and the case of Spenser’s The Faerie Queene follows a pattern somewhat similar to that of The Canterbury Tales, although its appeal and purpose and level of finish are very different. Reflecting much of the renewed Classical learning of the time—but lacking in Chaucer’s wit and variety, which only Shakespeare was to surpass—The Faerie Queene was conceived as a twelve-book allegorical tribute to Queen Elizabeth, but only six of its books were ever completed. Spenser began the massive epic in 1579, and he published Books I–III in 1590 and Books IV–VI in 1596, but he died in 1599, and only fragments of Book VII have been discovered. Like The Canterbury Tales, The Faerie Queene doesn’t conform to the scheme described in its introduction, and it’s unclear how Spenser would have resolved or reconciled the poem’s parts if he’d been able to finish and revise the entire work. John Milton claimed to hold The Faerie Queene as his great source in English literature, but this is generally viewed as self-crowning praise (because Milton vastly surpassed Spenser) and as a jealous snub against Shakespeare (who didn’t write epic poetry), but even though there are great treasures in Spenser’s work that have inspired centuries of writers, for most readers the labor of finishing this unfinished epic is rarely one of love.

The most unusual of all uncompleted literary masterpieces—in terms of both subject matter and textual history—is certainly the Marquis de Sade’s 120 Days of Sodom. De Sade was one of seven prisoners incarcerated in the Bastille at the beginning of the French Revolution, and although he was moved elsewhere ten days before what became known as Bastille Day (July 14, 1789), his manuscripts and belongings lay behind in the tower-prison and vanished when the Bastille was stormed, looted, and eventually destroyed. Many valuable manuscripts were lost, seemingly forever, but the one that de Sade considered to be his masterpiece—120 Days of Sodom—was the one that caused him to shed “tears of blood.” The manuscript describes the first thirty days of a ruthless and endlessly blasphemous libertine orgy of sex and violence, with notes outlining the following extremely well-organized ninety days. The thirty fully composed days make up a meticulously and gorgeously cruel progression through “the 150 simple passions,” while the notes sketch out “the 150 complex passions,” “the 150 criminal passions,” and “the 150 murderous passions” that were to complete the book. The extant “simple” passions alone are beyond shocking and force the reader to imagine the unimaginable and challenge the reader to consider that these words are simply words on a page and to suspend morality or judgment and simply read this work of literary terrorism. The manuscript was never publicly recovered during de Sade’s lifetime, and he spent the rest of his life and career lamenting his lost work while expanding his style and themes but never again recovering the sheer fury of his nearly inconceivable lost masterpiece. Luckily for us—or unluckily, depending on your point of view—the microscopically composed scroll was seized and saved during the storming of the Bastille, was passed to a family that saved it for three generations, and was then sold to a German collector named Dr. Iwan Bloch, who in 1904 published an altered and pseudonymous version of the text because of its “scientific importance.” After Dr. Bloch died, Maurice Heine acquired the manuscript in 1929 and subsequently published it in an authoritative edition under de Sade’s name, thus returning the unfinished masterpiece to its rightful author after nearly one hundred and fifty years. What’s nearly as amazing as the contents of the manuscript and notes for the unfinished book, however, is the author’s extremely astute list of “Mistakes I Have Made,” proving that de Sade had full mastery of his uncompleted work and that he knew how to make its horrifying contents even more effectively horrifying. Anyone who’s read this astonishing work can only marvel (and shudder) to imagine what it could have been.

In the twentieth century, two of the most exemplary (but very different) writers of the age—Franz Kafka and Marcel Proust—also both have famously unfinished masterpieces. Kafka’s completed short stories are perhaps the most perfect and resonant of our time, and even his fragmentary tales and parables and sketches offer endless riches, but he was never able to complete any of his three novels. Of the three, his second, The Trial, is clearly the standout masterpiece, but his first, Amerika, is hilariously strange, and his third, The Castle, takes the author’s labyrinthine method to its farthest extreme. The incomplete quests dramatized in these fragmentary works are often taken as reflections of our fragmentary times, and many critics read these novels’ unfinished stories as parables of the impossibility of attaining truth or personal autonomy in a world of bureaucracies and tyrannies. These readings often more reflect the critics’ circumscribed minds, however, because even though Kafka was frequently quite frustrated as an artist, it’s important for readers to remember that his final plan for The Castle included having his protagonist, K, attain his goal of finding access, meaning, and resolution within the seemingly impenetrable castle. Many critics ignore this fact, choosing to focus on the futility illustrated in these novels, and there is much to be learned in these kinds of readings, but as Hamlet says, “there are more things in heaven and earth . . . than are dreamt of in [this kind of] philosophy.”

Marcel Proust is often held alongside Kafka as the writer who most deeply reflected the lives and minds of modern humanity, but the style and approach of his (just barely) unfinished masterpiece, In Search of Lost Time, could hardly be more different. Although both writers address the frustrations of the outer and inner worlds that often confound the yearnings of the heart, mind, and soul, Proust eschewed the varied narrative approaches of the short-story writer—and even of the normal writer of separate or even sequential novels—and put everything he had into his one prismatic and all-encompassing mega-novel. Casting a wider and deeper net than that in any single creative work in history, Proust developed a vehicle in his 4,300-page novel that eclipsed the full scope of Dante’s Comedy and even rivaled Shakespeare in his endlessly swirling and metamorphosing cast of fully realized human characters. Proust’s novel is the true human comedy, and with the possible exception of St. Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Theologica (an unfinished masterpiece of an entirely different kind), In Search of Lost Time addresses more aspects of our existence than perhaps any other single piece of human writing. Like Aquinas’ Summa and Dante’s Comedy, Proust’s work is a construction that must be experienced from beginning to end, its progression of parts rising to a cathedral-like majesty as it builds toward its culmination. It’s an imperfectly completed cathedral, of course, as Proust’s death in 1922 halted his endless revisions and left dozens of narrative threads and characterizations unreconciled—and in fact left the novel with numerous gaps of lost time within itself. Proust came amazingly close to completion, however, and it’s only in the last volume, Time Regained, when the inconsistencies start to pile up their tiny bits of rubble. What’s truly amazing about this final volume is that it’s so brilliantly constructed and lit by such astonishing stained-glass illuminations that it nevertheless makes the thrust of the full work attain not just to the nearly perfect Chartres, but to a fully completed Beauvais. I’ve often thought of Dante’s Comedy as the literary equivalent of Chartres because of its minutely articulated organization of parts and subparts distributed throughout its sublime rose structure (see Erwin Panofsky’s excellent Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism for a penetrating discussion of the summa aesthetic in Gothic architecture), but perhaps the greatest literary cathedral isn’t the one that ends in perfectly balanced cosmic movement with “the Love that moves the sun and the other stars,” but the one that, like our own irreconcilable universe, leaves us continuously In Search of Lost Time.


—David Wiley


The imperfectly aligned west windows of Chartres





Friday, October 3, 2008

The Long and Woven Road: Dante, Chaucer, Shakespeare, and Sheep



The Long and Woven Road:


Dante, Chaucer, Shakespeare, and Sheep




Originally Published on About.com’s Classic Literature Page




The interweaving threads of literature, art, history, politics, commerce, and chance form a dazzling and labyrinthine tapestry filled with an amazing array of figures and narrative strands. In studying the Renaissance, one of the most fascinating realizations is that the creative literature in Italy didn’t come anywhere near the high peak that its visual arts reached during the “High Renaissance”—let’s give it an arbitrary summit date of 1504, the year Michelangelo dismantled the tiny womblike shack that he’d been laboring in for four years and presented his David to the world. Most of the great Italian writers of the time were the philosophers, historians, and political theorists who along with the great visual artists were rediscovering the marvels of ancient Rome and Greece, and in fact none of these writers can really be called “great” at all when compared to the Italian writers of the late Middle Ages who circled around and trailed Dante.

Conversely, the English Renaissance came to a peak about a hundred years later with Edmund Spenser, Christopher Marlowe, and the dizzying William Shakespeare and for some reason didn’t have a corresponding summit in the visual arts. It’s fairly easy to isolate the literary connection between Dante (& co.) and Shakespeare (& co.): The link is Geoffrey Chaucer, who seems to have absconded with Florence’s literary fire and taken it back with him to London. But in studying who influenced whom, the threads of circumstance reveal themselves to be as dizzying as the peaks that they connect.

The Triumph of Fame, from a set of
The Triumphs of Petrarch (1502–4), Flemish
(probably Brussels), wool and silk tapestry
Great artists almost always arise in centers of economic wealth and power, and the wealth of medieval and renaissance Florence came from its woolworking methods, which were the finest in Europe. Once the Florentines carded the wool, they exported it north to cities in Flanders, where it was used to make tapestries, which were some of the most exquisite and in-demand decorative works in the Western world. The catch was that although the Florentines had developed the best woolworking techniques (and networks) of the time, the sheep in Italy produced coarse wool, and so wool had to be imported from England, whose sheep have always been one of their most famous resources. Thus complex and fluctuating trading alliances and treaties connected these three areas to each other and to all of Europe.

A portrait of Geoffrey Chaucer, c. 1410s
in Thomas Hoccleve’s Regiment of Princes
Enter Geoffrey Chaucer. A budding young poet and a favorite of the English court, Chaucer became a diplomat and was granted many offices, including “Comptroller of the Custody and Subsidy of Wools, Skins, and Tanned Hides.” He was granted this office directly after a two-year diplomatic mission to Italy (1372–3), where he negotiated many of the political and economic alliances that bonded London to Genoa, Pisa, and Florence. As an insatiably curious man of about thirty, Chaucer marveled at medieval Italy and delved deeply into the literature of Dante, Boccaccio, and Petrarch, perhaps even befriending the latter two in Florence. Returning to England, his poetry shifted from his earlier French influences to a distinctly Italian-influenced style. While still in service of the court, he wrote many works that were considered to be masterpieces, particularly Troilus and Criseyde, but while on temporary leave (1386) and then in full retirement (1391 until his death in 1400), he worked on what became his true masterpiece, The Canterbury Tales.

An illuminated manuscript of The Canterbury Tales,
c. 1410, 
featuring a portrait of Geoffrey Chaucer
Deeply influenced by the storytelling structure and bawdy nature of Boccaccio’s Decameron, which was patterned both on Dante’s Comedy and Apuleius’ second-century Latin novel The Golden Ass (properly, The Metamorphoses), Chaucer infused the Italian influence with a wit and liveliness and vivacity of characterization whose depth of field was simply astounding. Having probably met Petrarch, he would have been familiar with Italy’s nascent interest in ancient literature, which had been brought about in part because the scholars of Constantinople had fled the invading Turks and taken their books to Italy, which hadn’t known Greek for a millennium and was eager to rediscover the wonders that had been lost to them for so long. Even Dante (who died in 1321) had never read Homer or Sophocles, and although Chaucer was never able to match Dante’s staggering greatness, his devilishly witty observations of human nature and his rich interplay of characters was unlike anything that even the ancients had produced.

He never finished his masterpiece, but after his death the fragmentary Canterbury Tales foisted Chaucer to a poetic status that England had never known. He became London’s state and world poet, as Homer had been for the Greeks, Vergil had been for Rome, and Dante was for Florence and then for all of Italy (and arguably for all of continental Europe). He was buried in a corner of Westminster Abbey in what has come to be known as Poet’s Corner, with him as “first poet,” and he remained first poet of England until, by some amazing combination of historical vicissitudes, intellectual influences, pure chance, and pure genius, a tanner’s son named William Shakespeare came along and filled his Globe theater with a world never seen before or since.

Detail from The Joust, from the Valois Tapestries
series (1560s–1570s), looking suspiciously like
William Shakespeare
In part, it was Chaucer himself who gave birth to the English Renaissance that produced Shakespeare, but there were many other midwives along the way. The Humanists of the Northern Renaissance, particularly Erasmus and Sir Thomas More, helped bring Greek thought to England, lifting the milieu that Shakespeare was born into just a little bit higher out of the Middle Ages. Then with Shakespeare’s stage thrusting him up to a peak that was surrounded by paths as elaborately woven as any tapestry made from English wool, the entire terrestrial globe was lifted even higher. What’s perhaps even more fascinating, though, is that these paths keep weaving themselves and never end. It’s only been 400 years since Shakespeare, and it’s possible that even greater peaks lay ahead.

—David Wiley



Thursday, September 25, 2008

Notes on Annotation: Ulysses, Pale Fire, and the Perils of Limited Professions




Notes on Annotation:

Ulysses, Pale Fire, and the Perils 

of Limited Professions





Notes are often necessary, but they are necessary evils.

—Dr. Johnson


Footnotes always seem comic to a certain type of mind.

—Vladimir Nabokov




Originally published on About.Com’s Classic Literature Page





Before I read the Annotated Student Edition of James Joyce’s Ulysses, I didn’t think there was much left to say about the art of annotation that Vladimir Nabokov hadn’t already illustrated in his 1962 novel Pale Fire. Ostensibly edited and annotated by an invented academic named Charles Kinbote (who turns out to be the mad, exiled king of the semi-mythic land Zembla), Pale Fire is a veritable map of misreading, a compendium of all the absurdities that could ever be perpetrated against a text by a so-called expert. Within the novel, Pale Fire is the title of a 999-line poem by Nabokov’s invented poet John Shade, and in a classic Nabokovian play of mirrors, the words “Pale Fire” lurk in the background of Kinbote’s 200+ pages of notes to the poem without him ever uncovering their source in Timon of Athens, which, in yet another Nabokovian gag, happens to be the only Shakespeare play that Kinbote has at hand, but it’s in his uncle’s Zemblan translation, and he can find no analogous phrase to the original Shakespearean lines: “The moon’s an arrant thief/And her pale fire she snatches from the sun (IV, iii, 437–8). Seemingly coincidentally, Kinbote even quotes his own retranslation of these lines from the Zemblan translation (“The moon is a thief:/he steals his silvery light from the sun.”), sending the reader on a hilarious goose chase that Kinbote has no idea about. It’s a perfect comment on the relationship between the artist and the commentator, the former a vibrant star reduced to a “Shade” by the latter—who, like Peter Sellers’ Quilty in the screen version of Lolita, ends up stealing the entire show. So hilariously feckless is Kinbote that even if he had discovered Timon’s statement that “there is boundless theft/In limited professions” (IV, iii, 426–7), he’d probably still have continued his notes as they were, unable to see that he was the butt of the entire joke.


Nabokov got the idea for the novel when he was translating and annotating Alexander Pushkin’s verse novel Eugene Onegin, a project that ran into several volumes and that dedicated three times as many pages to the notes as it did to the text itself. Nabokov prided himself on being a religiously literal translator and his version of Eugene Onegin as a completely transparent window into the original text, but he also saw the potential irony in his own authority as a Pushkin expert—his supposed objectivity a completely subjective thing—and saw how easily he could mislead or be misled in his task. Nabokov was something of an exiled king himself, and to explore the depths of how far his notes could have been led astray by his own precarious circumstances, he adopted Kinbote as his Bizarro-self, the self-styled expert who got almost nothing right.

One of the obvious (and cruelly unfair) referents here is James Boswell, whose Life of Samuel Johnson comprises much of what we know (and almost all of what we believe) about the eminent literary critic. There’s even a quote from Boswell’s Life at the beginning of the book. But Nabokov’s joke goes much farther than just commenting on the perils of sycophantic fire-stealing. Kinbote does a real disservice to Shade’s work and life and family, and it’s possible that he’s dangerous to more people than just his readers.

Discounting Kinbote (as we’re meant to, other than as a brilliant entertainment), the question of notes still remains: How do we navigate the hazy line of objectivity when it’s not an insane neighbor/colleague who gets his hands on the text, when there’s no clear line demarking scholarship from narcissistic self-hagiography? And what happens when that text happens to be James Joyce’s Ulysses, a book that the author boasted would have critics scratching their heads for centuries? It seems to me that critics living in the post-Nabokov age would automatically add Pale Fire to their repertoire of dos-and-don’ts before tackling such a project—that they’d laugh knowingly and then scramble to eradicate any Kinbotisms from their method. But with this new annotated edition of Ulysses, I think I’ve discovered an entirely new level of Kinbotian un-self-consciousness—and with it a brand new wrinkle to Nabokov’s game.

The Annotated Student Edition of Ulysses was published by Penguin Classics in 2000, and until recently it was only available in Europe and Canada (I got my copy at Shakespeare & Company in Paris, the namesake of Ulysses’ original publisher). The book is edited by Declan Kiberd, who provides ninety pages of introduction and 300 pages of David-Foster-Wallace-sized endnotes for the 900 pages of text. Kiberd is a professor at University College, Dublin, and his biography-blurb calls him the author of “many articles and television scripts,” which I guess gives him both academic authority and street credibility. Since it looks like Kiberd even wrote the book’s jacket copy (generously quoting his own introduction), this version of Ulysses seems to be entirely in his hands.

Kiberd’s launch into Ulysses begins plausibly enough, with his examinations of the book’s  structure, language, characters, and place in Irish literature starting out fairly even-handedly, but then as the introduction progresses, Kiberd’s biases, blind spots, and pet theories rise far above his exposition of the various critical views that he’s pretending to summarize. In the section on the book’s characters, he becomes absolutely (and endlessly) adamant about how Bloom represents the Androgyne (an opinion that seems to have some validity) and about how the book largely concerns discovering the ideal of genderlessness (which is an outrageous overstatement). When that section ends and the part on Irish writing begins, his diatribe on gender then spills over and shapes everything that he has to say about that too, as if Oscar Wilde’s homosexuality and the Celticization of the androgynous Shakespeare were the entire history of Irish literature. Kiberd also goes to great lengths to stress Joyce’s conformity to then-current critical ideas about gender, even when the Foucauldian and feminist approaches are at complete odds with the book’s evidence, much like when John Shade’s poem fails to live up to everything that Kinbote hopes to find in it.

As is often necessary, I figured I’d give Kiberd the benefit of the doubt and just navigate my way around the distortions and exaggerations that his obsequious academic fealties lead him into, but then just a few pages into the novel itself, I had an epiphany that put the pale fire back into perspective. When Kiberd’s notes strangely didn’t say anything at all about the word “Kinch” (Buck Mulligan’s nickname for Steven Dedalus), I looked it up in the OED (it means “A loop or twist on a rope or cord, esp. the loop of a slip-knot; a noose” [1]) and then saw that the entry two spaces above it was the word “Kinboot.” It struck me as I sat there with the dictionary in my hand that Nabokov must have done the exact same thing (Joyce fanatic that he was) and that for just that split-second I was in on one of his grand jokes. What struck me even more, though, was how quickly Kiberd had led me to Kinbote (which is a variant of Kinboot and which means “Compensation paid, according to Old English usage, for injury or wrong-doing.” The “kin-boot” is booty paid to the surviving kin of the deceased/murdered). When I saw that the two annotators had somehow become one—and that Nabokov’s shade had left me yet another text-game to unravel—I knew that Ulysses was going to be an even more amusing challenge with the notes than it was without.

Reading at about ten pages an hour, with the notes taking almost as much time as the text, I once again relished what Mulligan says to the Englishman Haines about Mrs. Cahill’s Irishisms: “That’s folk, he said very earnestly, for your book, Haines. Five lines of text and ten pages of notes about the folk and the fishgods of Dundrum. Printed by the weird sisters in the year of the big wind.” Joyce was clearly making a joke about how his own book would one day need extensive notes for anyone to understand it, but I doubt that even he could have foreseen how garbled the whole undertaking would become. (2)
Nabokov’s hand-drawn map of Ulysses’ action
Kiberd seems to have a fair grasp of the text of Ulysses (although there are many instances where he misquotes it in his notes [3]), but what seems to confuse him is what actually happens in the book. Presumably, he’s read all the other books of notes and references (his account of song lyrics and street names and political appointments and timelines is mostly pretty solid), but something about how he describes certain scenes makes me wonder how observant he is about what the book actually dramatizes. For example, when Stephen pees on the beach in the Proteus chapter, the waves behind him make a “fourworded wavespeech: seesoo, hrss, rsseiss, oos,” which Kiberd somehow interprets as the sound of Stephen’s urine. Similarly, on the beach again in the Nausikaa chapter, Cissy Caffrey tells Edy Boardman to take Tommy behind the pushcar “where the gentlemen couldn’t see,” and Kiberd writes in his notes, “the gentleman: Bloom,” somehow not noticing that the word “gentlemen” is plural. These are small annoyances that any attentive reader can ignore, but after a while they start to add up, undermining what credibility Kiberd actually does have. Another snowballing annoyance is the sheer number of notes Kiberd makes, about half of them either useless (nose out of joint: peeved; pistachios: nuts, P.O.: post office) or else wildly inflating any possible (or impossible) reference to gender. He’s also not very attentive to when and where words first come up: In the Cyclops chapter, when we’ve read the word “Gob” about half a dozen times (and easily figured out what it means), he finally notes its definition: “slang for ‘by God.’” And when words and references not directly concerning 1904 Dublin come up, it’s almost like you can hear him reading his annotations right out of his Zemblan dictionary. He annotates demimondaines as “people in the twilight world” (in a chapter concerning prostitutes!). He dutifully translates the words la belle dame sans merci (“the beautiful woman without pity”) but fails to note the connotations of the reference to Keats. And he annotates the Aurora Borealis as the “so-called ‘Northern Lights’ constellation.” And beyond even these are the plain Kinbotian weirdnesses. My favorite is Kiberd’s ongoing obsession with cricket, which he defines at one point as “the English national game, one of the subtlest sports.” It makes me think of Kinbote’s increasing annoyance over the very loud amusement park across the street (which later turns out to be a radio).

Joyce’s drawing of Leopold Bloom
Aside from all the annoyances and amusements, though, there are real, detrimental holes in Kiberd’s annotation. The most glaring is that while he picks up on anything even vaguely related to gender, he seems to have very little idea about another one of the book’s most important issues: Bloom’s Jewishness. Kiberd is sensitive to the existence of the Jewishness question, but he just doesn’t seem to know much about Judaism itself. He’s completely silent on the fact that Bloom doesn’t keep kosher (somehow even missing the scene in the Circe chapter when Bloom hides the pig crubeen from his father’s ghost). He fails to note that the “pillar of cloud” that Stephen mentions in the Scylla and Charybdis chapter, ostensibly “linking Stephen to Bloom,” is actually a reference to the Israelites’ Sinai wanderings. He annotates the words “ben Bloom” as “a pun on Slieve Bloom, the inland mountain,” which it may be as well, but he fails to note that “ben” means “son of” in Hebrew. He mis-identifies a Yiddish phrase that Bloom says to his father as German (!). And in the most astonishing lapse, he seems to have no idea what the rite of circumcision entails, either socially or physically. In the Nausikaa chapter, he fails to comment on Bloom’s reference to his foreskin (a reference that speaks volumes about Bloom’s identity as Jew and Irishman), and in the Ithaca chapter, when the narrative mentions Jesus’ foreskin, Kiberd notes that its relic had been “stolen by a centurion after the death of Jesus and conveyed after many removals to Calcata, near Rome.” Apparently, Kiberd thinks that the foreskin is something that’s still in place when Jews die, not only garbling the reference that he attributes to Don Gifford’s Ulysses Annotated, but betraying his utter ignorance of the most basic fact of Jewish male anatomy.(4)


Another major issue with this edition is its basic text, which reprints the original 1922 version of the book rather than the current critically accepted version. In 1984, Joyce scholar Hans Walter Gabler published a “corrected text” of Ulysses, incorporating approximately 5,000 emendations to the 1922 printing, ranging from tiny punctuation errors to entire sentence changes. Some of the changes correct the inevitable typos that Sylvia Beach’s small French press introduced into the book, but many changes derive from Joyce’s last-minute revisions to the serially published chapters that he then neglected to incorporate into the full text that was used for the book version. Gabler’s edition isn’t totally ideal, and Kiberd makes some very good criticisms of it in his introduction (along with many extremely petty and far-fetched criticisms of it), but the fact remains that despite its problems, Gabler’s text is the one that Joyce scholars currently use, and Kiberd doesn’t acknowledge this fact.  It’s not anywhere near as scandalous as Kinbote ferreting away Shade’s poem for his own use immediately after the poet’s spectacular death and manipulating Shade’s grieving widow into letting him edit and annotate it, but it does seem as if Penguin books just wanted to print its own new edition of the book, using a royalty-free public-domain version rather than either the Gabler or the 1960 edition (which was the previously preferred text) and that Kiberd took advantage of this opportunity, despite the larger consensus of the world’s Joyceans, a scenario that definitely seems a bit shady/Kinboty.

Recently meeting someone who’d studied with Kiberd, I asked about this edition, and the man just laughed and said of the professor, “Great guy, terrible scholar.” Then he simply added, “It could have been a lot worse.” Which, after weeding out the nonsense and really learning a lot from this edition, I guess is probably true.

Now that I’ve read Ulysses with Kiberd’s notes, I have this incredibly distracting annotator buzzing around in my head, doing his best to make Joyce’s book his own. But far more than that, I have Ulysses (or at least the Ulysses that was read by everyone from F. Scott Fitzgerald to Nabokov to Thomas Pynchon). And with so much of the staggeringly esoteric information plugged into the book’s vast formula, Kiberd isn’t all that hard to factor out. Joyce is such a luminary that an entire legion of Kinbotes couldn’t steal his fire. And since I’ve heard talk of an annotated Pale Fire in the works somewhere, I guess the next step here is for me to publish my own annotation of Kiberd’s annotation and snatch some of the fire for myself.

—David Wiley




1 This definition is as unsatisfying as any of the other explanations of why Mulligan calls Dedalus “Kinch.” Gifford’s note in Ulysses Annotated says that it derives from the word “kinchin,” which according to the OED is “the term used by 16th c. tramps to denote a [child] belonging to their community.” This makes a certain amount of sense, but it doesn’t explain why Dedalus is “Kinch, the knife-blade” (so many years before The Threepenny Opera [the term isn’t used in John Gay’s original version, The Beggar’s Opera, either]) or why the name tickles Mulligan so much (“O, my name for you is the best. . . .”). Some commentators simply assume that “Kinch” means “knife,” but there doesn’t seem to be any real basis for this. Looking into the stacks, I discovered a site in Greece called the “Kinch Tomb,” from around 300 BCE, but it seems like Kinch was the archeologist who found the tomb rather than the person buried in it. Then looking online, I came across a bunch of genealogy sites for names associated with “Kinch” (Kincheloe, Kinchella, Kinsella, etc.) and found an origin for “Kinch” that’s probably as close as I’ll be able to get without asking Joyce himself. According to Professor John Kincheloe of Meredith College, Raleigh, the surname “Kinch” originated with the twelfth-century Enna Cheinnselaig, the son of Dermot McMurrough (who named Enna after the fourth-century BCE warrior-king Enna Cinnsealach). In a typically gruesome medieval power-play, Dermot gave Enna over to his enemies as a hostage, and to prevent Enna from succeeding his father as King of Leinster, they blinded him (which Dermot did to his other son himself). This may have some bearing on Dedalus’ (and Joyce’s) poor eyesight and problematic relationships with pater and patria. And since the word “Cheinnselaig” has sifted down through the Irish language to mean “haughty, proud, or overbearing,” this might also have some relevance to the young bullockbefriending bard. It’s hard to say whether Joyce (or his character Mulligan) knew the story or the adjective, but since everything else eventually makes its way into Ulysses, maybe this is just another one of Joyce’s labyrinthine word-games.

2 The entire question of notes is a problem that not only gets at the heart of the reading public’s general bafflement over Ulysses, but that underlines one of the fundamental dilemmas of western civilization: the question of intrinsic versus extrinsic meaning/agency/salvation. Read solely from within its own parameters, Ulysses doesn’t seem to contain all of its own keys (unlike its great rival for Novel of the Twentieth Century, Marcel Proust’s In Search of Lost Time, which, rather than daunting you like a tower, surrounds and immerses you like a cathedral), and it’s this non-self-containment that keeps many readers from unlocking all of its levels—or from even entering it in the first place. So great is its humanity that Ulysses could have saved the world, had anyone in humanity been able to understand it, but unfortunately the only Bloom that this novel is meant to be understood by is Harold Bloom. (A) As a flesh-and-blood entity, Ulysses can thus be likened to the human body, which in Christian doctrine is formed imperfect and incomplete and needing an outside source to give it full life. Like the Eleusinian Mysteries of Greece and the Egyptian (and, later, Roman) cult of Isis—which both offer eternal life to their communicants—Christianity is a mystery cult, and it necessarily entails indoctrination (and exclusion). In St. Augustine’s view of eternity, even the greatest heights of pagan sublimity fell short of the required dogma, and it’s this position that worked to stamp out the Pelagian heresy of human perfectibility and that held sway over Western minds for nearly a thousand years, culminating poetically when Dante came along and finally raised a structure that matched the blueprint—a structure that, in an outstripping that would have greatly relieved St. Augustine, eclipsed even the Aeneid in sublimity. Aquinas, though (and, later, Erasmus, who read his Aquinas in a light that Dante had lacked, and who famously referred to Socrates as “Saint Socrates” in one of his Colloquies), had no need to damn Virgil, and he saw that many of the ancient pagans had achieved a moral greatness that was not only exclusive of Christ, but that far exceeded that of Christianity, which permitted torture as a means of conversion. While neither he nor any other medieval theologian would ever have gone so far as to think that eternal salvation could exist without Christ, Aquinas saw the human mind as a rational mirror of the divine universal mind, and despite the subtle counter-arguments of theologians such as Duns Scotus, who saw humanity as irrational, will-driven, and evil (the word “dunce” derives from the name Duns Scotus), salvation gradually came to be seen by the Humanists as intrinsic—as something built into our system and that could be attained from within rather than accepted from without—and it’s precisely this sense of intrinsic salvation that seems to be missing from Ulysses. With notes to explain what the fishgods of Dundrum are, Ulysses is one of the ultimate reading experiences, approaching the Aeneid and The Divine Comedy and even Hamlet at times, but even so, the barrier that the text puts up between the reader and the world that it portrays keeps it from standing on its own and functioning as an organic whole. In terms of linguistic agility and technical skill and attention to detail, Joyce far exceeds any other twentieth-century writer, but I have to admit that I prefer Proust (which may or may not be the criteria for what makes a book “great”). And even though Joyce is far more “post” than anything that the postmodernists achieved, I may even prefer Thomas Pynchon. (B) But then like no other book except the Bible, Ulysses is a hypertext that rewards with each new layer of interpretation and commentary and research. We read in Herodotus of Cyrus’ conquest of Assyria and are given an entirely new understanding of Israel’s release from its Babylonian Captivity in the Bible. And likewise Kiberd supplies the lyrics to “The Croppy Boy,” and all of Irish history bursts out through Joyce’s opaque prism. It may simply be that Ulysses is as great as the Bible and that all we need in order to save the world and ourselves it to read it repeatedly and faithfully. (C) Or maybe it’s just that, like the Bible, its greatness rises up from the fact that no one in the world understands it—or has really even read it. Like the Bible, we just accept its centrality because of what the authorities say about it.

(A) Anthony Burgess was wrong when said that Ulysses was for Everybody. Ulysses is a novel of democracy and equality and peace, but it’s organized in a way that systematically weeds out all but the intellectually elect. Leopold Bloom may be the great equalizer, but only the strongest are able to battle through the text to understand this equality (a conundrum that gets at another one of Western civilization’s great dilemmas: the question of top-down versus bottom-up).

(B) In addition to having a nearly endless wealth of innovation and variety and complexity and depth, Proust and Pynchon are both eminently rich in storytelling, in narrative development, in plot twists, and—especially in the case of Proust—in characters: all the other things that we normally want in fiction but that Joyce either refuses or is unable to give us. (I) Jorge Luis Borges said that Ulysses has no characters, only lists of traits. And as in Dante’s circumscribed labyrinth (or in Christian theology in general), there’s simply a lot that’s been left out. But in place of the swirl of storytelling that we’d hope to find in a novel of this scope, there’s a whirlwind of words and images and ideas and mini- and maxi-structures without parallel in any language. And even though he’s little more than a series of flashing thoughts, Bloom truly blooms in the reader’s consciousness into a living, breathing human being. It’s just that the pleasures of Proust and Pynchon are so extraordinarily great—and challenge us almost as much as Ulysses does—that my own scales of aesthetic bliss tend to tilt in their favor.

(I) One of the most startling aspects of Ulysses is the absence of any kind of story anywhere in the text. There are facts—and memories of facts—that slowly add up to a kind of history (especially in Molly’s soliloquy), but neither Joyce nor any of his characters ever tells a story to anyone: a remarkably deliberate omission in a culture of pubs and churches and funerals.

(C) Flannery O’Connor’s Misfit (from “A Good Man is Hard to Find”) said that Jesus “thown everything off balance,” and this may also be said of Joyce. With Ulysses, Joyce pulls out every stop imaginable, forcing us to disregard all the rules that normally apply to literature, and this may be argument alone for his literary deification. After Joyce, there’s not one jot or tittle left in its assigned place.

3 He sometimes gets word tenses wrong, or misspells names, or simply re-works Joyce’s phrasing to fit the form of the notes. I have a feeling that Kiberd, like so many of the academic types in William Gaddis’ novel The Recognitions, had an unreliable amanuensis.

4 Note to Declan Kiberd: The word “circumcise” comes from the Latin word circumcidere, which means “to cut around.” During circumcision, which for Jews happens on the eighth day after birth, the Mohel (or doctor, in the case of Gentiles like me) cuts the entire way around the penis, removing the foreskin altogether. The reason Bloom still has foreskin is because he was never circumcised.



Saturday, September 20, 2008

In the Shadow of Young Girls in Bloom: Proust, Nabokov, and the Tyranny of Memory



In the Shadow of Young Girls in Bloom:


Proust, Nabokov, and the Tyranny of Memory




Originally Published on About.com’s Classic Literature Page




Vladimir Nabokov
In his Lectures on Literature, which were originally delivered to his students at Cornell University in the 1950s, Vladimir Nabokov calls Marcel Proust’s In Search of Lost Time “the greatest novel of the first half of our century.” Although he makes this statement as an aside in his lecture on Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary, this is no mere throwaway remark. It may in fact be a vast understatement, as many critics consider In Search of Lost Time to be perhaps the greatest work in the history of narrative prose fiction. Whether Proust’s masterpiece surpasses Don Quixote or Moby-Dick or Anna Karenina (or its own near-contemporary, Ulysses) is a pointless question, of course; what matters is that Nabokov read Proust deeply and lovingly and with the eye of a master who was himself in the process of writing his own greatest masterpiece, Lolita.

On the first page of Lolita the narrator, Humbert Humbert, writes, “Did she have a precursor? She did, indeed she did. In point of fact, there might have been no Lolita at all had I not loved, one summer, a certain girl-child. In a princedom by the sea. Oh when? About as many years before Lolita was born as my age was that summer.” Although the immediate literary reference is to Edgar Allen Poe’s poem “Annabelle Lee,” in point of fact there might have been no Lolita at all had Nabokov not loved Proust’s In Search of Lost Time. The Proustian themes running through Nabokov’s varied works—the themes of time, memory, identity, sensation, jealousy, loss, etc.—have long been explicated by other critics, but it’s only in the last hundred pages of Proust’s final volume, Time Regained, the book that culminates the 4,300-page novel and that even few critics have actually read, that so many of these themes come together and create a new theme that Nabokov was to extrapolate to such an extreme extent in Lolita.

Marcel Proust, painted by Jacques-Emile Blanche
In recalling how he’d forced his much younger girlfriend Albertine, whom he’d first encountered by the sea, to relive and replay many of his memories of Gilberte, the girlfriend of his adolescence, Proust’s narrator (Marcel, for convenience’s sake) writes about how painful it is to realize that humans grow older while their memories often remains static and amber-trapped: “Indeed nothing is more painful than this contrast between the mutability of people and the fixity of memory, when it is borne in upon us that what has preserved so much freshness in our memory can no longer possess any trace of that quality in life, that we cannot now, outside ourselves, approach and behold again what inside our mind seems so beautiful, what excites in us a desire (a desire apparently so individual) to see it again, except by seeing it in a person of the same age, by seeking it, that is to say, in a different person.”

Humbert similarly forces the young “nymphet” Dolores Haze (aka Lolita) to replay the role of his lost Annabel Leigh, who died soon after their youthful romance by the sea. In her book Reading Lolita in Tehran, Azar Nafasi writes astutely about how the tyranny of memory can be forced upon the helpless, and when Lolita’s mother, Charlotte (whom Humbert marries to instate himself in the house) dies while running out into traffic after confronting him about what she reads in his diary—her flight an ostensible attempt to mail damning letters, but also perhaps a suicide—Humbert’s tyranny over the girl-child becomes complete. As he slowly discovers, however, he can ravage her by imposing his memory’s demands upon her, but as a living, growing human being, she will never be able to satisfy his static needs, the same way that Albertine was never able satisfy Marcel’s.

In the very final pages of Time Regained, the perhaps fifty-year-old Marcel makes his preparations to withdraw from society and finally begin writing his novel, but before doing so he asks the still living Gilberte, who has aged so much as to be unrecognizable and grotesque, to help introduce him to young girls. Gilberte is the daughter of Swann and Odette, whose unhappy love story forms much of Swann’s Way, the first volume of Proust’s novel, and whose patterns of frustration and betrayal formed the template that the young Marcel would relive in his relationship with their daughter and then later with Albertine. Seeing these patterns and realizing that real life could provide him nothing but dissatisfaction and that his only possible happiness lay in extracting life’s essences from his memory and turning them into a book, he makes this audacious last request of his childhood girlfriend not because he feels that he can find love with any of these young girls. He is far past Humbert’s stage of actually trying to relive the past with someone new. The second volume of Proust’s novel—the volume in which Marcel breaks with Gilberte and then later meets Albertine—can be translated as In the Shadow of Young Girls in Bloom (in the original French, À l'ombre des jeunes filles en fleurs, with the “en fleurs” suggesting young girls getting their first period), and in making his request to Gilberte, it’s simply the bloom of youth that he wants to be near, to caress in his free time and to use to refresh his aging senses as he delves through their sense-stimulus into the deepest recesses of memory to create his book.

Gilberte’s response to his request is beyond audacious. Unlike Lolita’s mother, who perhaps chooses death when she discovers Humbert’s monstrous nature, this child of Swann and Odette simply perpetuates the past yet again by presenting Marcel with her own teenage daughter. “I thought her very beautiful,” writes Proust’s narrator, “still rich in hopes, full of laughter, formed from those very years which I had lost, she was like my own youth.” The pattern now reset, this exquisite girl, this “masterpiece” of time, as Proust describes her, is now, like her literary successor Lolita, fated to relinquish her hopes, her laughter, her bloom, and the very time that her existence has allotted her to be young and free, to be subjected to the inexorably fixated imagination of a sick old man obsessed with recapturing his own lost time.

—David Wiley


Monday, September 1, 2008

Taxi, by Khaled Al Khamissi



A Review of Khaled Al Khamissi’s Taxi



Originally published in the Rain Taxi Review of Books, Fall 2008



Taxi
By Khaled Al Khamissi
Translated by Jonathan Wright
Aflame Books ($14.95)


“. . . mostly U.S.A. is the speech of the people.”
—John Dos Passos, U.S.A.


Khaled Al Khamissi’s fascinating new book, Taxi, is a collection of fifty-eight fictionalized experiences with cab drivers in the author’s beloved and detested Cairo. Taxi drivers are in many ways the voice of the street, creating in this book a kind of oral history in which every story is filtered through dirty windows and is therefore wholly subjective and impossible to verify. After hitting a pedestrian and continuing on his way, one of Al Khamissi’s drivers begins a tirade about Egyptian hospitals that leads to a discussion of the 2006 ferry disaster in the Red Sea, and after detailing his (perhaps credible) account of the ensuing coverups and conspiracies, the driver admits, “I heard this from people and I don’t know where the truth is and where the untruth.” In fact, even much of what Al Khamissi reports as statistical fact about his own subject comes from the subjects themselves. He writes in his introduction that there are 80,000 taxis operating in greater Cairo and that this staggering number is the result of two specific government decrees, but then—far into the book, after having absorbed dozens of stories with this larger picture in mind—the reader discovers that Al Khamissi learned this information from a taxi driver.

Despite its numerous layers of human filters (including translation from Arabic), Taxi is a strikingly immediate portrayal of the lives of Cairo’s struggling cab drivers. Al Khamissi sometimes acts as interpreter and judge of the book’s more extreme moments, but mostly Taxi is the speech of the people, reproduced simply and in the style of the streets. His drivers tell him of endless ripoffs, financial disasters, health and family struggles, corrupt police, and trails of red tape that seem to interweave the nightmares of Kafka with the labyrinths of the Arabian Nights. Each driver is a Scheherazade trying to fend off death for just one more day, and many of them work for days on end without sleep simply to pay the car’s owner and continue working. (Al Khamissi notes that “calculated scientifically… it’s 100 percent a losing proposition.”) As I’ve personally witnessed in innumerable Egyptian taxis, the cars are death traps whose mandatory (and extremely expensive) seatbelts don’t work, and with the also mandatory, expensive, and nonfunctioning meters serving as literal dashboard ornaments, there’s no way to calculate fares without haggling with each customer every time.

For the drivers stuck in this life, these cars are true death traps heading inexorably toward the grave, but as in any life, which inevitably taxis us toward the same destination, Taxi offers moments of levity, quiet joy, and even transcendence. The drivers’ voices ring with pleas for pity, perhaps only to be answered in the end by God, but we are all on the same journey, and these voices deserve to be heard.


—David Wiley